Gaming's Great Debate!

Cheese wrote:ODST wasn't good.

It was the only game I couldn't be bothered to play through right now. Halo 2, on the other hand, had glaring flaws but I still think is underrated.

FUCK YOUR MOTHER!

I stand by ODST and all its awesomeness.

I voted for Halo, but I do think that the CoD game that no one has heard of is still awesome. CoD: Finest hour for PS2. No multiplayer, but still good. The ambiance is amazing.

Cheese wrote:ODST wasn't good.

It was the only game I couldn't be bothered to play through right now. Halo 2, on the other hand, had glaring flaws but I still think is underrated.

This.

Gauz wrote:

Cheese wrote:ODST wasn't good.

It was the only game I couldn't be bothered to play through right now. Halo 2, on the other hand, had glaring flaws but I still think is underrated.

This.

BULLSHIT GAUZ!

ODST was a great game, just overpriced compared to other games on the market (because of a lack of any kind of matchmaking and PvP). Still, I thought it was worth every penny.

i voted for evenly good, cod2 doesn't hold its multiplayer becuase theres a new cod game every year with a new version coming out people switch.
how many of you are going to switch primarily to reach's multiplayer once it comes out.

i personally prefer the halo series becuase halo is fun, cod is competetive, i dont give two shits about my KD in Halo, in cod it feels like you dont have fun unless you have over 1.5 witch you dont either above or below that line.

Hell i even prefer halowars to CoD's multiplayer. but CoD's campain is on equal ground with halo 3's. Nothing compares to Halo 1 so i am keeping it out of my judgement.

All around game, Halo
Best Co-op Campain, Halo
Best Special Co-op, CoD
Best Multiplayer, Halo
Best Graphics, CoD (Unless Reach sways me)
Longevity, Opinion
Thus Halo>CoD by 1 department

I like playing against friends on CoD, Halo's gotten boring for me.
Hopefully Reach will do something about that.

But K/D is so much more random in CoD - based purely on the time it takes to kill someone by shooting them in the back of the face.

Nathan Fillion made an appearance in ODST...








-20 points.

Ringleader wrote:Nathan Fillion made an appearance in ODST...








-20 points.

You don't like anything at all, do you?

Nathan Fillion is in Castle damn it!
But I suppose you hate that too, do you?

I don't even know who Nathan Fillion is.

So...Doesn't effect my point score.

Ring doesn't like Nathan Fillion

-100 (days from your life span)

ODST was alright, but the addition of Fillion was just a marketing tool that really added nothing to the game, because when your playing the game and you see Nathan Fillion, you think: "Oh, that's Nathan Fillion I guess... Wait, why is he in Halo?"

The completely unnecessary addition of Fillion just made it seem like some kind of big Hollywood production or something, I mean, he's an actor, not even that great of one for that matter (especially his voice acting), so why throw him in? It's not really that big of a deal, certainly not one to make the game go from good to bad, but the devs decision to throw him in is sort of like throwing in a barrel rolling space fighter with turbo boosters. In all, I'd give ODST a 7-8, but like most games, there are certain little nitpicks that keep the it from being great.

ODST just didn't feel like a complete game to me, like, most of Halo is an online experience, and all ODST had to offer in that department was Firefight, something you wouldn't want to play more then one game at a time.



"C'mawn Verawnica, wacoubeMMMORE immportn thn that Carrier?"

When you have to come out with 6 games to keep a crowd going - compared to just an expansion - you know the game isn't really that great.

CoD's campaigns have never had any replay value to me (especially when they don't have co-op) except to get laptops and death cards. Even with MW2's "special co-op" I only played through it till I had the stars, then I never came back. I'd still gladly replay Halo 3 or ODST's campaigns, though. Only Nazi Zombies really kept me coming back to any CoD game, and that's even wearing off much faster than Halo 3.

As for multiplayer, Halo definitely takes the cake. It's better balanced, has constant support from Bungie (even now), has forge and a great gametype editer, and just flat out has better games IMO.

And who is Nathan Fillion?

He's the main character of Firefly, a 'Space-Western' series...